The New "Religion Vs Science" Thread

Search
Go

Discussion Topic

Return to Forum List
This thread has been locked
Messages 8621 - 8640 of total 10585 in this topic << First  |  < Previous  |  Show All  |  Next >  |  Last >>
WBraun

climber
Jan 5, 2018 - 03:26pm PT
Meaning is a product of eternity.

Everything in the whole cosmic manifestation is a product of eternity.

You are over educated and have lost your soul .......
paul roehl

Boulder climber
california
Jan 5, 2018 - 03:37pm PT
Really enjoying the depth and subtlety of these fine arguments.

My point about the perception that eternity is prerequisite to meaning is that it remains a vestige of Christian belief systems and yet ironically permeates the ideas presented by those that are anti-religion. Meaning it seams to me can only be what we make it and we should celebrate that fact and that meaning as every bit as valid and important as what would be found in what might be the eternal and in a sense it is the eternal.

but you understood the sentence.

Actually, no.

which is at least a goal or posting to this thread

What does the above mean?
sempervirens

climber
Jan 5, 2018 - 04:56pm PT
which is at least a goal or posting to this thread

Looks like a typo:
... a goal OF posting to...
Lennox

climber
in the land of the blind
Jan 5, 2018 - 06:28pm PT
Meaning it seams to me can only be what we make it and we should celebrate that . . .

I can agree with your sentence up to that point. The rest of the sentence is awkward and unclear, but based on what I think you mean, I’d say it cannot be supported and is unnecessary.



. . . fact and that meaning as every bit as valid and important as what would be found in what might be the eternal and in a sense it is the eternal.
WBraun

climber
Jan 5, 2018 - 06:36pm PT
Meaning it seems to me can only be what we make it

You can't "make reality"

It always is "As it Is"

You are over educated and lost your soul .....
Wayno

Big Wall climber
Seattle, WA
Jan 5, 2018 - 06:49pm PT
Oh great another witch.

lol.+222

"This conspicuous behavior will get you nowhere, young lady!"
jogill

climber
Colorado
Jan 5, 2018 - 08:26pm PT
Really enjoying the depth and subtlety of these fine arguments


;>)


Clearly meaning is both necessary and sufficient to reducing eternity to a sniveling mass of chronons that lack coherence with regard to probability waves. But that's the simple part.
High Fructose Corn Spirit

Gym climber
Jan 6, 2018 - 09:14am PT
Like Jordan Peterson's put it: Humanity bears a heavy load...

She Fought for Dignity Under the Law.

https://www.thedailybeast.com/she-fought-for-dignity-under-the-law-she-died-of-stab-wounds-naked-in-the-snow?source=twitter&via=desktop

Civilizing is hard.
High Fructose Corn Spirit

Gym climber
Jan 18, 2018 - 11:33am PT
The story of Lubna Yaseen picked up by The Atlantic...

The Underground Railroad to save atheists in the Middle East...


https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2018/01/the-underground-railroad-to-save-atheists/550229/?utm_source=twb

Good work Richard Dawkins and Center for Inquiry!


This...
“I believed in my rights to be who I am,” -Lubna

This despite her culture, despite her language, despite her religion.

an Arabic translation of Dawkins’s book The God Delusion has reportedly been downloaded by more than 10 million people, with about 30 percent of downloads (3 million) coming from Saudi Arabia.

...

[Click to View YouTube Video]
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4IJRkUXQ9zI
Mark Force

Trad climber
Ashland, Oregon
Jan 23, 2018 - 05:35pm PT
We don't make reality - Wener is right that reality is "As It Is."

We train our reticular activating system to filter reality around us for what we've "told" it we want to be aware of in the world around us based on what we've chosen to focus on.
Lennox

climber
in the land of the blind
Jan 23, 2018 - 10:11pm PT
paul roehl

Boulder climber
california
Jan 24, 2018 - 07:42am PT
Think of all the millions of people that have found help through their faith. Be it a belief in Christ or any other of the thousands of gods offered up in religious belief, think of the great benefit religious faith and practice have offered.

Is religion the opiate of the masses? You bet it is and when you're really hurting opioids are a damn good thing.
sempervirens

climber
Jan 24, 2018 - 08:08am PT
Good posts Malemute. I think one has a slight error though. Were Adam and Eve created with the original sin? I thought they were without sin until Eve at the apple and then God created the rest of us with the original sin because of them.

Think of all the millions of people that have found help through their faith. Be it a belief in Christ or any other of the thousands of gods offered up in religious belief, think of the great benefit religious faith and practice have offered.

That is a good point. Also, Think of all the millions of people that have been murdered, raped, mislead, ostracized, sacrificed, beheaded, and/or manipulated to vote for tyrants by their faith. Be it a belief in Christ or any other of the thousands of gods offered up in religious belief, think of the great atrocities religious faith and practice have offered

How can you reconcile that? Are those benefits worth the trade offs? The atrocities are the result of religion.

What if we could hold onto the benefit of religion and drop the blind faith? That way, we could keep all the ceremony that people seem to love but remove the authority and all the bs from the Billy Graham types who deliberately manipulate the sincere but gullible believers.
paul roehl

Boulder climber
california
Jan 24, 2018 - 09:11am PT
As Nietzsche said, “why man at all?” Or we might ask why consciousness at all? And “behind every great human destiny there sounded as a refrain a greater ‘in vain!’ “

Something is lacking in our existence: how to justify, to account for, to affirm ourselves. And virtually all human beings find suffering in their lives. How do we endure that suffering? By giving it or finding in it some sort of meaning. Humanity is, in fact, inclined to suffering if that suffering is predicated on some sort of meaning.

We suffer from the problem of meaning.

As Nietzsche said, “The meaninglessness of suffering, not suffering itself, was the curse that lay over mankind…”

Without that meaning our plight is the existential unknown and the fearful void of pointless suffering and pointless achievement.

Religion enables that meaning.

Religion brings fresh suffering with it, though the enforcement of religious practice usually has more to do with political impositions than spiritual practice, but no matter, now that suffering makes sense in terms of a granted meaning.

Christian Martyrs in the arena went to their deaths singing and smiling, willingly and they deeply impressed Roman Pagans. Delusional? Perhaps, but they made the exit we all have to eventually make with a minimum of fuss and you might even say Joy.

Ultimately religion has done much more to civilize humanity, turn humanity to the good than it has done evil. Remember: people kill people religion doesn’t kill people.


sempervirens

climber
Jan 24, 2018 - 10:11am PT
Ultimately religion has done much more to civilize humanity, turn humanity to the good than it has done evil. Remember: people kill people religion doesn’t kill people.

No problem with Nietzsche's discussion of suffering.

How much has religion benefitted or harmed humanity? How can you quantify that? If you can't quantify it then you can't defend your statement.

If religion encourages or demands killing people then doesn't it bear some responsibility for the killing? Granted that not all religions or religious people support killing, but many of their texts do. And since religion demands faith in its own doctrines, religion is at fault regardless of other nice things it might accomplish. Take credit if you wish, but then you must accept blame too.
paul roehl

Boulder climber
california
Jan 24, 2018 - 10:49am PT
How much has religion benefitted or harmed humanity? How can you quantify that? If you can't quantify it then you can't defend your statement.

Common sense tells us that the far greater number of human beings practicing some sort of religion today don't engage in the imposition of those beliefs or murder or war or any of the other things some atheists like to blame them for. Quantification is as much your baggage as it is mine: before you condemn them what "quantity" of believers are imposing their views on others, murdering in the name of religion and so on?
Ward Trotter

Trad climber
Jan 24, 2018 - 10:53am PT
Religion enables that meaning.

But first, religion must enable the suffering. Religion, perhaps spiritualism in general, appears to fabricate, or reconstruct the universe around suffering as an a priori condition.

Nothing about human life as fashioned by natural history elevates suffering above and beyond other human experience. Both love and suffering are determined by man's unique and naturally evolving organic nature.

Before this was discovered , mythological forms held primary sway over the human mind. They were great scripts , and like most scripts needed heroes aplenty to struggle over and defeat the implacable outcomes of an apparently meaningless cosmos-- a cosmos like Tara in Gone With The Wind , not built upon soft Georgia clay but rather " upon hard suffering to its very core."

sempervirens

climber
Jan 24, 2018 - 11:09am PT
I'm condemning religion but not for the quantity of its crimes. I mentioned quantity because you brought it up as a defense of religion but your statement is unsupported. So far, you're still unable to support it.

My condemnation of religion is due to its demand of blind faith and the inherent problems of blind faith.

I haven't claimed to be an atheist nor do I speak for atheists.

... I'll await Werner's "stoopid" reply....



paul roehl

Boulder climber
california
Jan 24, 2018 - 11:18am PT
But first, religion must eneble the suffering. Religion, perhaps spiritualism in general, appears to fabricate, or reconstruct the universe around suffering as an a priori condition.

When you realize what life is, a kind if Ouroboros devouring itself in a compelling directive of survival, life feeding upon life in order to continue and as well its naturally short and brutal nature and the probability that most in the paleolithic period probably died from things like tooth decay, suffering seems to be intrinsic to what is and hardly a construct of any kind.

Religion gives suffering meaning and in doing so we are inclined toward it as we are to all meaning.

The great wisdom of Job is that that meaning is unknown to our understanding but nevertheless there, an opioid to our dilemma.

My condemnation of religion is due to its demand of blind faith and the inherent problems of blind faith.

Then make an argument against faith.

Again, common sense tells us there are many more faithful practicing their faith peacefully than not. To think other wise is absurd.
Ward Trotter

Trad climber
Jan 24, 2018 - 12:03pm PT
When you realize what life is, a kind if Ouroboros devouring itself in a compelling directive of survival, life feeding upon life in order to continue and as well its naturally short and brutal nature and the probability that most in the paleolithic period probably died from things like tooth decay, suffering seems to be intrinsic to what is and hardly a construct of any kind.

Suffering is intrinsic but no more intrinsic than love, betrayal, failure, gladness and the recognition of natural beauty-- therefore suffering need not be needlessly and existentially elevated to a priori status just because it provides the scriptural tension required for a good story. Such promotional tweaking thereby catapults suffering into the artificial realm of the iconic construct; because it must be fleshed out, hyper-extended, and made a modus operandi for nominally unrelated cultural forms.

BTW , I know this sounds like quibbling, but there is perhaps just as much death attributable to tooth decay in the contemporary world as in the paleo. Absent absolutely horrendous climactic conditions at various times, paleo humans experienced fairly good dental health , all things considered. Despite not having dentists they got a lot more sun, which resulted in much higher Vit. D sulfate levels as well as a generally higher redox potential (both essential to good dental functioning)-- factors modern humans are often deficient in, due to indoor living, primarily. Once humans invented agriculture and therefore aggregated into much larger settled communities the major culprit became infectious diseases.( The one thing noticed of bed- ridden invalids is that their dental health deteriorates rather quickly , absent intervention. This is due to a disconnection from nature, in general. The mitochondria in their gums, and jaw, as elsewhere, are little electrical engines deprived of optimal levels of incoming solar energy)

This characterization of life being "brutal and short" -- as compared to what? I suppose as compared to Valhalla or some other heroic throne of the gods where organic human life has been transmogrified into the purely ethereal-- thereby validated in ways safe from the draconian critique otherwise reserved for the savage life of tooth and claw and an unheroic, ignominious death from tooth decay.
Messages 8621 - 8640 of total 10585 in this topic << First  |  < Previous  |  Show All  |  Next >  |  Last >>
Return to Forum List
 
Our Guidebooks
spacerCheck 'em out!
SuperTopo Guidebooks

guidebook icon
Try a free sample topo!

 
SuperTopo on the Web

Recent Route Beta