Your worst climbing mistakes. . .what happened/why?

Search
Go

Discussion Topic

Return to Forum List
This thread has been locked
Messages 76 - 95 of total 112 in this topic << First  |  < Previous  |  Show All  |  Next >  |  Last >>
Rusty Royden

Trad climber
Los Angeles
Aug 19, 2010 - 08:18pm PT
Was directing a rock climbing exercise for kids at a Y camp involving 7 climber/instructors at 5 stations for some 30 kids. Got an emergancy call from one of my TR instructors. After instructing the rest of the team by radio to end thier exercises I dashed over to the staion that had called in the problem to find A kid dangling 15' up from his leg loops with his harness belt open. The kid didnt panic and the belay lowered him out. A quick investigation revealed that an untrained camp staff member had taken it upon herself to "help" by putting kids into harness's. She of course failed to double back the buckle. This occurred right under my nose as I was supervising the other climbing staff. A quick check found 3 other kids waiting their turns at various stations with improperly fastened harness buckles.
RR
docsavage

Trad climber
Albuquerque, NM
Aug 19, 2010 - 08:33pm PT
Long time listener, first time caller....

This thread actually inspired me to create an account. Where to start? Two episodes, in fact, stand out.

Attempting to free up a route in the Sandias (Duck Soup on Chaos Crag). Had done the crux 3rd pitch & set up a belay for the last when the sky opened up. Lowering off I misjudged the amount I had traversed, neglected to clip the lead line & wound up hanging in space 30 feet away from my partner's belay. Still don't know how I got back to him - you definitely won't find it in any manual. Worst part was, by that time the weather had passed but I was too freaked to continue....

Later I was leading a new route on the sandstone bordering El Malpais in New Mexico (since made off limits by the Acoma tribe), a splitter finger-&-hand crack widening to an off width, with a moderate escape right. Now off-widths are not my forte but this one, being kind of offset, called for a sketchy layback more than anything else. Besides there was that great ledge above. It wasn't. Again, don't know how I got back down. Multi-purpose lesson: Be sure & bring extra shorts....
ruppell

climber
Aug 19, 2010 - 08:45pm PT
4th of July weekend I was climbing at Bart Dome. Finished the climb and was in a hurry to get down and do the next one. It was my first time at the dome but from the guide it looked possible to get off with one rope with some small raps. Well the first rap is this weird rap into a chasm. You actually have to rap way off to climbers right as you chimney the chasm. My partner was not happy with this at all. We both got down and searched for the next rap. This one happened to be off of a huge chockstone with at least ten pieces of webbing. After double checking the slings it looked safe to me. I threaded the rope through the rap rings and looked at the 50 or so feet to easy 3rd class and my pack. Still in a hurry I put the bight of rope through my belay device and put that into my locking biner. I leaned back and felt the usual rope pull tight. I started my rappel. About ten feet down this slightly overhanging rap I notice my harness is riding really high on my right side. This is new I think as I look down to see what the problem is. The problem it turns out is that I was "clipped in" to my gear loop instead of my belay loop!! Knowing the ground was only 40 feet or so away I kept rapping quickly and smoothly. One thing that I thought as I reached the ground was "Thank You Yates" the other was "Are you a Friggin idiot". I took a lot of lessons from this one.
Charlie D.

Trad climber
Western Slope, Tahoe Sierra
Aug 19, 2010 - 11:04pm PT
Most of mine occurred like most victims: after a couple years climbing, feeling comfortable and not knowing what you don't know.

Combine that with the fact we just started to drive to the crags and drink on our return in the mid sixties with no seat belts, metal dash with pointy cool looking knobs looking at you like bullets it's astonishing I'm alive. Good old mom claims it was the power of prayer, something more than just dumb luck.

Anyway, the worst? Too numerous to mention, teach your children well.
mjb

Trad climber
Point Pleasant, NJ
Aug 20, 2010 - 09:47am PT
Pulling onto the summit of lizard head just as the sun set in the distance, shorts and a tee shirt. Moonless night, couldn't see my own shoelaces, clipped into rappel backed over the edge heard a click, thought to myself, "Shouldn't be no click noises" hand over hand back to the top find the rappel gear completely disconnected from my harness.

Now that will make an impression on you!

Steven Amter

climber
Washington, DC
Aug 20, 2010 - 05:46pm PT
I've got three ancient history stories:

1) The first was in the summer of 1976, the first season I ever climbed out west and in the big mountains. My Buddy Andrew and I (both 20, having climbed for 2 years) had hitchhiked from NYC to Eldo Canyon and, arriving tired the night before, we, slept in. But boy were we jazzed to do our first Colorado climb! We were inexperienced, but pretty strong (Gunks 5.9; 5.10 by todays standards) trad leaders. We decided to do the classic Bastile Crack, but didn't start until something like 1:30 PM... so of course, three pitches up a few hours later we are huddling and terrified, rain and hail coming down in torrents, lighning hitting all around us! The afternoon thunderstorm abated, we finished the climb, and down in the parking lot we were informed by some older, wiser, bemused locals that there is almost always an afternoon thunderstorm in the front range.

Lesson learned: know your local climate.

Later, Andrew made a confession to me: that morning as a joke, he had written something in his climbing log something that did not seem so funny in retrospect, to the effect of: "Dear Mom, we are about to go on our first Colorado climb. But try as might, I can't fake life any more. I want to end it. Today. I think I'll take Steve with me." I guess that would have made for an interesting accident report.

2) Same trip, same partner, in the Indian Peaks area of Colorado, along with some more other experienced mountaineers who were helping us improve our mountaincraft. Neither Andrew nor I had crampons or ice axes (we were travelling really light for hitchiking), so we split off from the group for the day determined to stay only on the trails and rock bands and avoid anything dangerous. We ascended some minor peak successfully, but on the way down kept encountering icy snow fields that we had to circumvent. At the top of one snow chute, I told my buddy, "stay here while I scope this out." I cautiously ventured onto the top, relatively flat part to get a look down it: an obvious nightmare. It was long, quickly became steep, and ended in a horrendous field of boulders and snow. I turned partially back to Andrew to tell him: "its no good, its a death slide," and promptly slipped onto my ass.

What happened next was straight out of a Roadrunner cartoon: I sat there trying to gain traction, but it was hard and slick. I could feel myself ever-so-slowly slipping down onto the steeper slope, helpless to prevent it. After about 10 seconds, suddenly I lost all control and flew down the slope.

Andrew later said I seemed to simply take off and vanish from sight. The other climbers we knew, who were looking up at us from about 1000 feet below and from the side, who had been wondering "what the hell are they doing on that slope without ice axes?" were now thinking "sh#t, he's a dead man for sure."

Although I was moving really fast, the length of the slope gave me plenty of time to think on the way down. I tried a series of strategies to stop myself. First I tried to self arrest with my heels and elbows. Nothing! I flipped over on my stomach an tried my fingers and toes in the classic arrest pose. The snow was too hard - again nothing. Knowing my appointment with the boulders at the bottom of the snowfield was imminent, almost on a whim I decided to flip onto my back and at least see what was going to give me the chop. I also had this vague idea that maybe since I had pretty strong legs, they could absorb the hit and somehow let me survive - this decison probably saved my life.

What happened next happened at hyperspeed, but somehow seemed to occur in slow motion. I remember hitting a refrigerator sized block squarely with my legs in a semi-squat position. This promptly fipped me over onto my stomach, going headfirst down the slope. By some miracle of speed, trajectory, and slope angle I was somehow skimming over the boulder field in superman postion. I could feel my hands slapping at the rocks beneath me as I hurtled over them. After what seemed a long time, I found myself crumpled against a car-sized boulder in softer, flatter snow.

I lay there for a while, my whole body trembling and numb. I was sure both my legs were broken, at the very least. After a time, I became dimly aware that voices had been calling my name. "Steve, are you all right?" I responded: "I don't know." I lay there for a bit more, than pulled myself up into a sitting position. Andrew eventually arrived at my side, having descended down the rocks adjacent to the snow, and was looking very concerned. "Steve, you look f*#ked." It took me a moment to realize what he was talking about - I hadn't noticed that my clothes had been partially peeled from my body. My gloves and my mountaining parka were in tatters. My heavy climbing pants had mostly been shredded off my legs. But - I didn't see any blood or really bad scrapes, and a self check revealed that I could move everything.

With help from Andrew and my other friends, I painfully stiff-legged it back to basecamp, to spend the next seveal days lying in the tent. Although I had a few scrapes and some impressive bruises, for the most part I was entirely unharmed. I never really could explain how I had managed to fly over something like 35 feet of boulders and not get seriously hurt. My friends who had a distance view of the whole incident said I seemed to skim above the rocks without really hitting them. I took the incident as a wake-up call and the very first thing I did when I hit a town with a mountain shop was buy a killer SMC iceaxe, even though I could ill afford it. Its a honey and I still have to this day.

3) Okay, this is the last one. In about 1986 I was climbing in Tucson, AZ's awesome wilderness climbing area, the Reef of Rocks. I was on the first crux of the third pitch, leading a hard 5.11+ which, in retrospect, I had a slim chance of on-sighting. While moving past a fat stopper I had plugged in on a steep, strenuous, fingery section of the climb, the bizzare happened: my foot brushed against the top binner of the quickdraw, and somehow managed to clip my (doubleknotted) shoe lace). Suddenly I was trapped, unable to move up or down! Fighting to hang on, I executed a series of increasingly desperate, spastic foot kicks which eventually pulled the stopper. Now, with the gear hanging off my foot, I was high above my last piece, with no placements, with my arms rapidly fading. I was too spent to downclimb the crux section, so I was forced to pull a couple of moves higher. With a last bit of strength, I got in a good piece, and gratefully sagged onto it in the middle of the face. But I was not done yet...

After my heart (and my ears - you know the feeling?) stopped pounding, I stubbornly decided to decide to complete the pitch. Even though I was still somewhat pumped, I didn't want to look wimpy to my climbing partner (who was the far better climber) and the second crux, an exciting overhang with a thin edge at the lip, lay ahead. I began to climb again. I led high into a corner to reach the overhang, walked my hands along the lip, threw up a high foot, then a heel hook, and semi-blind placed my trusty custom 2/3 inch tri-camming unit in a shallow crack. I couldn't really see it, but I knew it was possible to get a good piece in there.

And than I ran out of gas.

Try as I might, I could'nt make the long reach to the next set of handholds to allow me to pull the roof. After struggling for a while, and then trying to reverse the sequence, I spun off the roof and fell sideways. First I felt the camming unit pop. I fell a bit further on to my next piece and felt/heard that sickening thing no climber ever wants to experience - a harness tearing! Hanging off-kilter in mid-air, I looked down and saw that I torn through one of the leg loops of my favorite (and obviously too old) harness. Defeated (and little bit unnerved), I lowered to the belay ledge so that my partner could waltz up the route.

Final lesson learned: even though the harness looked ok ("just a little worn in some spots") never compromise on your gear. Tragedy lurks!

Well, that was certainly long-winded. It wasn't originally my intention to write a tome, but I must say it was really fun reliving past terrors from the safety of my office chair. Hope you kind of enjoyed it too..


guido

Trad climber
Santa Cruz/New Zealand/South Pacific
Aug 20, 2010 - 08:34pm PT
Talk about getting lost and mistakes. Posted previously.

Alas, here is a photo of Galen crossing the Merced when we went up to climb the Worst Error in 1962 and never found the correct route so we made a first ascent. Appropriate that we named it the Real Error. Oh what a cock-up!





hb81

climber
Aug 20, 2010 - 08:50pm PT
Not getting into climbing until I was 26.


But I still have plenty time to mess up and come back to this thread I guess. :))
Dr.Sprock

Boulder climber
I'm James Brown, Bi-atch!
Aug 20, 2010 - 09:15pm PT
my worst mistake is probably about to happen,

so i don't make mistakes unless i know about them in advance,

by then, it's junk food, like a mc steak sandwich,

or lunch meat, like spotted owl or beagle,

whoopin crane or eagle, it's all lunch meat to me,

some say save the baby seals, they might get hurt,

i say save the baby seals, save them for desert,




rottingjohnny

Sport climber
mammoth lakes ca
Aug 20, 2010 - 09:36pm PT
rapped off of penny pinnacle and was 4 ft shy of the next rap ledge...i un did my leg loops , ( days before harnesses ) and tried to reach the ledge with my toes....no dice...my swami began to tighten on my chest and suffocate me...i quickly learned how to make a prussic knot and solved the problem...then lived happily ever after until i discovered this white stuff in my water bottle...rj
jfailing

Trad climber
A trailer park in the Sierras
Aug 20, 2010 - 09:38pm PT
Steve - that story of your trip down the snow field was great! Glad you ended up miraculously okay...
Tfish

Sport climber
La Crescenta, CA
Aug 20, 2010 - 11:52pm PT
After bitching out on a lead when I was learning to lead I didn't want to leave a biner so I clipped in direct to the 3rd bolt, un tied and put the rope through the hanger and got lowered off. I'm stoked I used my buddies rope for that kook move.
skywalker

climber
Aug 21, 2010 - 12:25am PT
Led the second pitch of country club crack with the intention of setting a top rope on the second pitch lower and belay from the ledge on top of the first pitch. Never climbed with that partner before. This was standard business with other regular partners. Got to the top, built the anchor and yelled O.K.! Backed off and fell ~90 ft??? until the rope came tight to his anchor on said ledge. He thought I meant off belay. Thank God it was the second pitch and its steep! Didn't hit anything but blew the rope apart. We went home...

S....
Mimi

climber
Aug 21, 2010 - 12:44pm PT
Hello there Steve Amter! Great story.

Guido, that is a wild scene in that photo! True adventure.
docsavage

Trad climber
Albuquerque, NM
Aug 21, 2010 - 01:40pm PT
Steve - great stories! My snowfield story involves trying to negotiate one on EB rubber ... 'nuff said.

Charlie - remember when a seatbelt was your mom throwing her arm across you?
k-man

Gym climber
SCruz
Aug 21, 2010 - 07:56pm PT
I once made the mistake of listening to my partner on the approach to the Chouinard-Herbert on the Sentinel. He said "It has to go up here..." pointing to a dead tree leaning against the rock, after which a 5th-class ramp went up and right.

"We're not supposed to rope up yet," I said. Then I pointed up and left and said "The climb is over there!"

Arguing with this bloke was of no use, so after a minute I acquiesced and uncoiled the rope for him to start the lead. I knew full well that this would be the end of our "ascent."

A move or two up the tree, and this guy actually slips and falls off, lands right on me, and falls past. His lead rope sawed the inside length of my bare arm, giving me a deep rope burn that ended my climbing season.

I looked at him in disbelief and said "I can't believe you just fell on me."

Then the pain hit.
Captain...or Skully

Big Wall climber
Transporter Room 2
Aug 21, 2010 - 07:59pm PT
Goin' general....made a bunch.
Not dead yet!!!!
Who's the joke on now? Yowza.

Groove on, my brethren.(sisstren, too.) ;-)
nutjob

Gym climber
Berkeley, CA
Sep 15, 2011 - 03:27pm PT
Bump because there are lots of great stories here!
nutjob

Sport climber
Almost to Hollywood, Baby!
Apr 2, 2013 - 09:02pm PT
I just ran across this again, laughed a bunch and puckered a bunch and sweated a bunch with such good stories. And then the final laugh when I was about to bump it, was reading that I was the last one to bump it a few years ago :)

Anybody got new ones to add?
rockermike

Trad climber
Berkeley
Apr 2, 2013 - 09:26pm PT
winter solo of north ridge of Mt. Stuart; 1980 or so. Bunch of sh#t went wrong on that trip, but the best was when I dropped my tool. 45 degree water ice, with a 200 ft cliff below. I drop one of my tools and it cartwheels a couple hundred feet, then sticks in some soft snow a couple of feet above the drop-off. So I delicately down climb the ice with one tool, but slip maybe 50 feet from the brink. Saw my life, and said my prayers expecting the worst. Then I too came to a stop when I hit the soft snow just above the cliff. Picked up my lost tool and continued up into more mayhem. fun was had by all....
Messages 76 - 95 of total 112 in this topic << First  |  < Previous  |  Show All  |  Next >  |  Last >>
Return to Forum List
 
Our Guidebooks
spacerCheck 'em out!
SuperTopo Guidebooks

guidebook icon
Try a free sample topo!

 
SuperTopo on the Web

Recent Route Beta