help climbers visciously attacked in Peru

Search
Go

Discussion Topic

Return to Forum List
This thread has been locked
Messages 521 - 540 of total 796 in this topic << First  |  < Previous  |  Show All  |  Next >  |  Last >>
Patrick Sawyer

climber
Originally California now Ireland
Jan 11, 2013 - 03:49pm PT
Jebus, if you come to Ireland, come around for a cup of tea, or coffee or a hot whiskey. It would do us both a lot of good. Langdale, 7 Burmah Close, Dalkey. And the rock in Dalkey Quarry (good granite) is a five-minute walk from my front door.

And I promise that the locals will not stone you and chase you for 10 or so minutes. I'll do that. ;-)
mechrist

Gym climber
South of Heaven
Jan 11, 2013 - 04:04pm PT
Jebus, you from NuhVAAAAAAduh? I wonder how these "climbers" pronounced Peru... and other words. If ever in Prescott Aridzona... it is Presskit, not Prescott.

[Click to View YouTube Video]
Patrick Sawyer

climber
Originally California now Ireland
Jan 11, 2013 - 04:54pm PT
Jebus, a good stoning eh?

Though I haven't partaken recently, there is some decent green or hash around. If you are telling me you are coming over I can score. And don't even think of bringing your own stash, the risks are too HIGH.

That said, I could use a good toke now after Jennie's tantrum in the village (which she has forgotten, that's dementia). I just have to settle for a glass of wine.

Cheers dude.

Paddy
Patrick Sawyer

climber
Originally California now Ireland
Jan 11, 2013 - 05:25pm PT
Jebus, the stone in Dalkey Quarry is sound granite (and some choss but not much, however you are looking at 10-40 meter climbs, but some two-pitch climbs (albeit short) for the most part, but great granite, slab, face, cracks.

And then there is Glendalough, multi-pitch (yeah, like three rope lengths at best) on decent granite. Fairhead in Northern Ireland, 1-4 pitches and you have to be a solid 5.9/HVS climber to lead. There are other places in Ireland. But the west (Cali, Nevada, Oregon, Idaho, Washington), gosh aren't we so blessed. And of course other places (Chamonix, Patagonia, Alaska, Andes, Himalaya, etc).

Forgive me if I am crying. I miss home and the stone that is there. There is nothing like Tuolumne Meadows in the summer. Sigh...
blahblah

Gym climber
Boulder
Jan 11, 2013 - 05:29pm PT
. . . caught boulder poaching once, on Hunter Ligget army base, by some staff Sargent M.P.

What's a "Sargent"?
graniteclimber

Trad climber
The Illuminati -- S.P.E.C.T.R.E. Division
Jan 11, 2013 - 05:39pm PT
Patrick Sawyer"
This thread seems to be turning into a "what if" thread.

The means you are about to do add your own "what if":

Common sene. My mom taught me that. I wonder if the three so-called heroes (a term used on a couple of websites now) used their common sense. Two beers among three people to celebrate a birthday? Come on, let's be real. Only two beers. Poor souls must have been broke to only afford two beers.

Common sense should tell you that not all of us are Irish drunks! I know if must be foreign concept to you (no pun intended on your being in Ireland) but some people are able to drink in moderation, and drink less beer than they can afford to drink. Even on their birthday.

Just because you like to get tanked on your birthday and drink till the money runs out doesn't mean that everyone does that.

Me, one my birthday I only had one beer. Most other people there had only one beer or none. It wasn't that we couldn't afford any more--there was plenty left over in the cooler.

So what may be "common" sense in Ireland or anywhere with a group of drunks might not be as common as you suppose elsewhere.
Big Mike

Trad climber
BC
Jan 11, 2013 - 05:46pm PT
Heh. Yeah, that's sort of my ode to the idiocy of anglicizing a Spanish word and then getting bent out of shape when people honor the roots.

funny how people get bent over pronunciation... When I was in the valley I couldn't get over other climbers saying "RAAAUWWWWT". Finally I asked someone about it in the hotsprings one night. I said "It's a Route!" (rou-te) and the guy says, "What are you, French?"

it is a french word....
sempervirens

climber
Jan 11, 2013 - 06:52pm PT
If it waddles like a duck, quacks like a duck... then it is probably a duck.

I can't believe I'm responding to this....
But you forget that there are many kinds of ducks whose behaviors may be very different. Thirty year old Nano puff wearers from Idaho who drink beer might not all have the same attitude and behavior. That's why the duck theory doesn't work. It is simple prejudice. Don't fall for it.

I've even heard that there are some Irishmen who talk like Irishmen, dress like Irishmen and walk like Irishmen but ARE NOT drunks. Is that true?

I tried to explain this to Riley.
WBraun

climber
Jan 11, 2013 - 06:59pm PT
You people are fuking crazy and obsessively out of control with this bullsh!t .....
Hardman Knott

Gym climber
Muir Woods National Monument, Mill Valley, Ca
Jan 11, 2013 - 07:00pm PT
What else would you expect from fuking stupid Americans?
blahblah

Gym climber
Boulder
Jan 11, 2013 - 08:04pm PT
blahblah go hump someone else's leg, mkay?

DMT

how about save your endless circle jerk for your buddies or your own BS threads--you've got plenty, mkay?
Ian Westmoreland

climber
Jackson
Jan 11, 2013 - 08:32pm PT
I came here to post in this thread. I didn't join this forum to talk about climbing or any of that.

I been living in Jackson Hole for nearly 20yrs. Things have changed a lot here in the last decade, before the word was out about JH it really was mostly nothing but dirt bags here but those days are long gone along with many of the real dirt bags. I traveled by my own vehicle from JH to Panama and back, twice, with my dog. The first trip I spent living out of my truck on the road, did 15k miles in 4 months on the trip. On my second trip I bee-lined it for Panama and spent the next three months living in a small village of about 300 people. So just making it clear I do speak from a perspective that is based on experience.

When I first read the Wolfrom's story I thought it was a scam or just some other crazy BS, just couldn't wrap my head around it. Now, a week later and a few dozen hours of my own research and I believe their story to be true. However, I feel it is so very one sided and much is left out of the tale. Their story is full of holes, without a doubt. The money thing is lame and shows character of all those involved or who donated to them. I don't really care about the money side of it but I do think it speak volumes about many things, the credit of the people telling the tale only being one of these things.

I hate to come right out and say it but I feel it needs to be said. These three folks were extremely ignorant. I feel in at least a small way they do reflect upon me not just because they are from JH but because I take trips myself in my own vehicle deep into Latin America. As such, I do feel the need to comment on various discussions (on the internet) on the topic of the Wolfrom's tale. Getting your teeth kicked in and losing all your sweet gear is a hefty price to pay for ignorance but when you go to somebody else's country you are playing by their rules not your own. If you don't know the rules than really you have no right to say if you were dealt with in any way that is not acceptable in the said country.

There is a whole lot of factors that come into play from the incident. Fact of the matter is, the Wolfrom's account is full of so many holes it is hard to believe it took place as they describe. I won't go and point out a bunch of the details which have already been pointed out a number of times in this thread. However, the Wolfrom's posted their story for the world to see, themselves along with family and friends solicited the story to be spread as much as possible and as fast as possible. They (I don't care if it was friends/family) also solicited for money which they got to the sum of over 20grand. They did all this within 5 days after the were attacked, yes I suppose we can thank modern technology for that. I am just stating facts here. My issue with them doing that is that it shows them (because they are) irresponsible people and travelers. No insurance, no back up plan, no emergency fund, ect ect is irresponsible any way you look at it. And hey we have all been guilty of being irresponsible but most people admit this and then are willing to deal with the consequences of it. If I got a beat down like they did and then robbed I sure wouldn't be posting it on the internet asap for the world to see unless I had ulterior motives. A simple paragraph would have been enough for the world to see without pasting their police report or whatever it was on their blog along with an itemized listing of their lost gear. By doing that they have opened themselves up to scrutiny and rightly so.

I feel it is good that not everyone is buying their story. I think it is good there are ongoing discussions about the incident on the web. Why? Because it helps to shine a lot of light on the one sided story we have been given. It may also (if the Wolfrom's read these things being discussed about them) make them think about going on TV as well as to think back on the event and reflect. By reflecting perhaps they can realize they are mostly to blame for what happened to them. Perhaps they will realize all the mistakes they made to cause this to happen to them and perhaps they will understand why they are being scrutinized so much. If not, well then they have a long hard road ahead of them in life.

I read some 400 comments in this thread so have not read them all. Having been into overland (travel by vehicle) travel for some time now and also an active person within that community. Well, I got to say I am not to stoked on the kinds of things I read in blogs by travelers doing these kinds of trips the last few years. A big lack of respect is shown in travelers blogs across the web reporting on these types of trips, not just the Wolfrom's. And it disgusted me.....

I have not seen this link provided yet in the 400 or so comments I read so here ya go, another perspective.

http://chichalimona.blogspot.com/2013/01/what-really-happened-in-ocongate.html

You can clearly see by some of the well informed comments posted in that blog that there is much the Wolfrom's didn't know about the country they were traveling in. That is foolish on their part, especially if you are just planning to camp where ever you like in a country you know little about.

There is also an ongoing discussion in the overland community, however, not many people are offering up much besides a few people. most are content to just wish them well and be silent. Which I got to say bothers me too since the Wolfrom's are a reflection on this community.

http://www.expeditionportal.com/forum/threads/81198-adventure-americas

Bottom line, your trip of a lifetime can be ruined if you are foolish and ignorant. On top of that you have a responsibility as a traveler and should not be so hasty to tell tales like the Wolfrom's since you are part of a much larger community. I do not fault them for seeking help, I do however question the way and method they went about seeking help. I know that if I got a beat down and lost my stuff I sure wouldn't be in a hurry to tell the world about it. Perhaps because in every part of my life I look to what I do/did to cause something to happen to me. And as a result I would feel embarrassed if I was the Wolfrom's. I mean really what do they expect from the public after telling their tale and so on and so forth?

Cheers
Big Mike

Trad climber
BC
Jan 11, 2013 - 08:57pm PT
There is also an ongoing discussion in the overland community, however, not many people are offering up much besides a few people. most are content to just wish them well and be silent. Which I got to say bothers me too since the Wolfrom's are a reflection on this community.


This is what a lot of people here seem to wish would happen also.


I know that if I got a beat down and lost my stuff I sure wouldn't be in a hurry tot ellt he world about it.

Yet it was their first priority!

Something happened for sure. What? I don't know, but their story is missing something...


They didn't press charges, and they haven't updated since they got the money, and no other media seems interested in the story.. Fishy.
graniteclimber

Trad climber
The Illuminati -- S.P.E.C.T.R.E. Division
Jan 11, 2013 - 10:24pm PT
Bottom line, your trip of a lifetime can be ruined if you are foolish and ignorant. On top of that you have a responsibility as a traveler and should not be so hasty to tell tales like the Wolfrom's since you are part of a much larger community.

Criticism falls into two contradictory categories (both bullshit):

1. Parts of Peru are full of crazy bloodthirsty savages. If you there without an escort, or at least without an escort, you're stupid and deserve everything that happens to you.

2. Peru is perfectly safe, full of well-meaning but ignorant, non-Internet connected peasants. None of them would ever hurt a fly, unless the fly deserved it. If anything like this happens to you, you must have totally provoked it.

Clearly Ian Westmoreland is a category 1 guy.

But I don't understand. He blames them for being "foolish and ignorant" in stopping in that area, but also attacks them for mentioning it on their blog. I guess he wants them to keep it secret so that the next "foolish an ignorant" traveler will make the same mistakes.
graniteclimber

Trad climber
The Illuminati -- S.P.E.C.T.R.E. Division
Jan 11, 2013 - 10:29pm PT

A pishtaco is a mythological boogeyman figure in the Andes region of South America, particularly in Peru. In some parts of the Andes, the pishtaco is called kharisiri, or ñakaq.[1]

According to folklore, it is pagan evil monster-like man, often a stranger and often a white man, who seeks out unsuspecting Indians, to kill them and abuse their bodies in disgusting ways, primarily by stealing their body fat for various nefarious cannibalistic purposes or cutting them up and selling their flesh as fried chicharrones. Pishtaco is derived from the local language Quechua word: "pishtay" which mean to "behead, cut the throat or cut into slices".2]
Preoccupation with body fat has a long tradition in the Andes region. In pre-Hispanic times, fat was so prized that a deity for it existed, Viracocha (Sea of fat). It is also natural for the peasant rural poor to view fleshiness and excess body fat as the very sign of life, good health, strength and beauty. Many illnesses are thought to have their roots in the loss of body fats and skeletal thinness is abhorred.[3] The Indians were horrified when they saw the practice of the Conquistadores of treating their wounds with fats taken from enemy corpses.[4]

Spanish missionaries were feared as Pishtacos by the Andean aboriginals, who believed they were killing people for fat with which to oil churchbells to make them specially sonorous.[5] In modern times similar beliefs held that human fat was needed to grease the machinery of sugar mills[6][7] or that jet aircraft engines could not be started without a squirt of human fat.[8] Pishtaco beliefs have affected international assistance programs, e.g. leading to rejection of the US Food for Peace program by several communities, out of fears that the real purpose was to fatten children, and later exploit them for their fat.[8] Survey geologists and other Europeans working on the Peruvian and Bolivian altiplano have been attacked by natives in the belief that they were Pishtacos.[9] The work of anthropologists has been stymied because measurements of fat folds were rumoured to be part of a plot to select the fattest individuals later to be targeted by Pishtacos.[7] In 2009 the Pishtaco legend was cited as a possible contributory factor in the apparent fabrication of a story by Peruvian police of a gang murdering up to 60 people to harvest their fat.[10]

The pishtaco is prominently referenced in the novel Death in the Andes by Mario Vargas Llosa. In the book, two members of the Peruvian Civil Guard investigate the disappearance of three men, trying to determine if they were killed by the Shining Path guerilla group or by mythical monsters.[11]


Yeah, I'd agree that it's ignorant, although not necessarily foolish to not know about the ignorant and foolish superstitions of some of the locals.

But I doubt that they though they were being paid a visit by Pishtaco Man, although it may be a convenient theory to tell the cops.
happiegrrrl

Trad climber
www.climbaddictdesigns.com
Jan 11, 2013 - 11:04pm PT
The blog has no new entries, but the Facebook Page has one, yesterday.
https://www.facebook.com/MegaJed

Jenny, Jed's sister is finally back in the good ol' USA!!! We are happy she is back safely, but it was hard to say goodbye to her! Our car is back in Cusco and the windows are being replaced. The mayor of Ocongate is supposedly going to pay for it, but we will see if that actually happens or not.
Jed apparently received 6 unneccesary root canals while in Cusco, but because they were also done so poorly he is having to have them all re-done before he can begin the process to get his new teeth. OUCH! Wish him luck in the upcoming days!

OUr bodies ache less and less every day and our spirits grow stronger. We go this afternoon to get our stitches out of our heads.
It has been a crazy 9 days since the incident and we are still looking at about another week of running around, but then we should be able to get the hell OUT OF PERU !
To everyone who has sent us messages of support,... Please know that they have meant a lot to us, and even though we have not yet had the time to sit down a and respond individually we have enjoyed reading them! Your support means a lot to us! Thank you!
abrams

Sport climber
Jan 11, 2013 - 11:46pm PT
Hurray! Moving on to new horizons.

google says the area they got attacked in is where the potato genetically originated. All wild species and domestic cultivars came from that area of the village of stone tossers. think of that next time your stuffing mcdonalds fries down the hatch
murcy

Gym climber
sanfrancisco
Jan 12, 2013 - 12:00am PT
"... and finally, if you do go there, we recommend not ordering a 'fishtaco'."
Todd Eastman

climber
Bellingham, WA
Jan 12, 2013 - 01:12am PT
I recall the Pishtaco thing causing some problems for Canadian mining operations and mineral exploration companies working in Peru several years ago.
Jan

Mountain climber
Okinawa, Japan
Jan 12, 2013 - 01:31am PT
Jed apparently received 6 unneccesary root canals while in Cusco, but because they were also done so poorly he is having to have them all re-done before he can begin the process to get his new teeth.

It seems like these guys have poor judgement concerning just about everything. Really if your front teeth were knocked out, would you consent to 6 root canals before getting them replaced? In a Third World Country?
Messages 521 - 540 of total 796 in this topic << First  |  < Previous  |  Show All  |  Next >  |  Last >>
Return to Forum List
 
Our Guidebooks
spacerCheck 'em out!
SuperTopo Guidebooks

guidebook icon
Try a free sample topo!

 
SuperTopo on the Web

Recent Route Beta