Discussion Topic |
|
This thread has been locked |
WBraun
climber
|
|
I never said anything like this either.
You really are weird.
You keep trying to put your words and thoughts into other people. (projection)
You keep revealing your true self.
That you are very unintelligent.
|
|
WBraun
climber
|
|
Whether one sees God or not is not the issue here.
You guys make so many unintelligent statements to support your conclusions .....
|
|
High Fructose Corn Spirit
Gym climber
-A race of corn eaters
|
|
EDIT - Poster deleted his/her thread.
you seem to want to force your non-belief as well
First, one operative word above is "seem." I suppose it might "seem" this way to you. Esp insofar as youre coming from a Christian perspective.
Second, it's modern times in America, so nobody on this site is desiring or intending to "force" their ideas on anyone. (Not that I can tell at least. But who really knows, I mean really. Maybe a supertopian (Ed, maybe, or Nature) at some point met up with Go-B or Klimmer - in perhaps a dark forsaken descent somewhere - and threatened them with a blue cam to convert - really I do doubt it but if so I'd love to hear the tale.)
Third, speaking for myself, I don't have "non-beliefs" - I have beliefs and plenty of them. Last I checked millions of Christians didn't believe in evolution or in an automatic free-running nature independent of any divine supernatural superintendent. Millions of traditional fundamentalist Christians along with Muslims didn't believe they are an integral part of nature. Moreover, millions more didn't believe its possible that everything they are could be a result of mechanistic cellular metabolism at work by the trillions of microscopic parts. Or that all of this magnificent Creation en total could result from something called a big bang. (And I could go on.) So who exactly are the non-believers?" That's the point, here. And who exactly harbor the non-beliefs? Don't you see, it is a matter of perspective and framing.
And I for one, am tired of always working out of the Christian perspective, always having to deal with Christian rhetoric and bias in language and thought; it's time for change, and I feel it coming along nicely.
A believer, I am
in science and science edu
in modernity and human civilization and its continuation
in the good life
P.S.
I had some issues with the rest of your post and its peculiar wording, too, but don't have the time to address them.
Carry on...
|
|
High Fructose Corn Spirit
Gym climber
-A race of corn eaters
|
|
Sigh. Most atheists give other atheists a bad look.... Most atheists I know are so "scientific," they're more annoying than the believers themselves.
michaeld, hope you're not speaking to me. P.S. Either way, I can't agree with your broadbrush statement. Seems pretty shallow.
.....
So cool off and let this thread die
You wish. Atheism (as a clearing agent for bigger and better things to come) and other irreligious, nonreligious or post-religious groups are just getting started. It's the information age now and things are just starting to heat up. Hallelujuh!
.....
One issue the michaeld post does point out is that even among the irreligious - perspectives, attitudes, interests and values vary. All that unites them is an interest - mild in some, passionate in others - to push beyond the supernatural theism. I can imagine, in 100 years, when there are hundreds of millions of irreligious or nonreligious people milling about, no doubt I would find a lot of them disgusting in their interests or values.
|
|
Binks
climber
Uranus
|
|
I like Alan Watt's answer:
If you believe in God I don't.
If you don't, I do.
I don't believe in religion or holy books or priests, ministers or any institutionally appointed guru of any stripe.
|
|
HighTraverse
Trad climber
Bay Area
|
|
MissJ
A short SuperTopo history of "life".
Someone started a thread called "I Like My Pathetic Life"
And then another thread appeared "I Like the Climbing Life"
Then "I Like My Pantheistic Life"
"I Like My Agnostic Life"
...life
...cereal life
..Thug Life
..Night...
..Bit'er...
...Tantric...
I Like My Christian Life
and finally this thread.
Do we need a "get a life life" thread?
Considering that evangelical conservatives have been trying to merge religion with politics for the past 30 years, contrary to the prescient 1st Amendment, quite a few people have actually come out of the Agnostic/Atheist closet.
You got a problem with that?
Oh, and some of my good friends are practicing Christians, Jews, Muslims, Hindus and Buddhists. So no, I don't have any problem with your beliefs......as long as I can have my own, or lack of.
|
|
MisterE
Social climber
|
|
Werner Braun must be one of the most narrow-minded people that have ever posted to a religious thread, he can't even see past his own righteousness, let alone beliefs.
It must be a very fixated place to not allow any other considerations of beliefs.
|
|
P.Rob
Social climber
Pacomia, Ca - Y Que?
|
|
because Werner is an admitted believer in god and Christianity
and absolutely no one, no one, has ever called him stupid for his belief
I know at first blush Werner can seem ….. Well harsh. But I have come to believe he is being ironical & honestly subtly self deprecating, with the twist to not take ourselves so seriously.
I can not state on his commitment to “Christianity” and I have never seen such a post as him saying as such …….. Even back in the early 80’s I had always heard he was committed to the study of Vedic writings and the concept of Karmic debt.
The one and only “conversation” I had with Werner is when I asked him where the crux was on a certain climb ………….. The answer – one of the all time best “The Crux is the hardest move for you”
|
|
P.Rob
Social climber
Pacomia, Ca - Y Que?
|
|
Why don't you Christians head to the Christian thread.
Cuz I love you Spirit man - and you know thats true. Besides the Christian page got hijacked by "y'all" pretty quick. And in truth Mr.Spirit you in particular give cause to thought. I do not want to join some bless me club - I like to bang and clang ..... and you are pretty good at it.. most of the time
|
|
Jingy
climber
Somewhere out there
|
|
because some people just delete their posts...
|
|
P.Rob
Social climber
Pacomia, Ca - Y Que?
|
|
Sorry P. Rob, there are always exceptions, but face the facts. In a country, by all measures extremely religious, only 7% of eminent scientists (those elected to the National Academy of Sciences) believe in a personal god.
I have been pondering this Mr.Donini
The “religious” tend not to be a codified or homogeneous, rather an amalgams or mosaic in their chosen bits and pieces. If you take these religious poles and drill down the definitions of “faith” are quite murky and muddled.
I also wonder if those in the National Academy of Sciences are being transparent in their answering of theses questions, seeing how reactionary the thought of “god believers” in their midst.
While some see intelligence as an antidote to being infected by the God Delusion, obviously its efficacy is not 100%:
Richard Feynman, Nobel prize in physics in 1965, was a very unusual person. He said some 9 years before receiving the Nobel prize, "Many scientists do believe in both science and God, the God of revelation, in a perfectly consistent way." So is it possible to be a scientist and a Christian? Yes according to Richard Feynman.
Now one could regard that statement as strictly anecdotal. Americans love statistics. Here's the result of a poll of the professional society Sigma Zi. Three thousand three hundred responded, so this is certainly beyond statistical uncertainty. The headline says, "Scientists are anchored in the U. S. mainstream." It says that half participate in religious activities regularly. Looking at the poll is that 43% of Ph.D. scientists are in church on a typical Sunday. In the American public, 44% are in church on a typical Sunday. So it's clear that whatever it is that causes people to have religious inclinations is unrelated to having an advanced degree in science.
Michael Polanyi
Let go a little deeper with a statement from Michael Polanyi, professor of chemistry and then philosophy at the University of Manchester. His son, John Polanyi, won the Nobel prize in 1986. I think that it's probably true that when John Polanyi's scientific accomplishments, which have been magnificent, have been mostly forgotten, his father's work will continue.
Michael Polanyi was a great physical chemist at the University of Manchester. About halfway through his career, he switched over to philosophy. He was equally distinguished there. His books are not easy to ready. His most influential book is called Personal Knowledge. He was of Jewish physical descent. He was born in Hungary. About the same time he switched from chemistry to philosophy, he joined the Roman Catholic church. He said,
I shall reexamine the suppositions underlying our belief in science and propose to show that they are more extensive than is usually thought. They will appear to coextend with the entire spiritual foundations of man and to go to the very root of his social existence. Hence I will urge our belief in science should be regarded as a token of much wider convictions.
Michael Faraday
My very favorite—and probably the greatest experimental scientist of all—is Michael Faraday. The two hundredth birthday of Michael Faraday's birth was recently celebrated at the Royal Institution (multi–disciplinary research laboratory in London). There was an interesting article published by my friend Sir John Thomas, who said if Michael Faraday had been living in the era of the Nobel prize, he would have been worthy of at least eight Nobel prizes. Faraday discovered benzene and electromagnetic radiation, invented the generator and was the main architect of classical field theory.
Let me contrast the end of his life with the end of Lev Landau's life. Faraday was close to death. A friend and well–wisher came by and said, "Sir Michael, what speculations have you now?" This friend was trying to introduce some levity into the situation. Faraday's career had consisted of making speculations about science and then dash into the laboratory to either prove or disprove them. It was a reasonable thing to say.
Faraday took it very seriously. He replied:
Speculations, man, I have none. I have certainties. I thank God that I don't rest my dying head upon speculations for "I know whom I have believed and am persuaded that he is able to keep that which I've committed unto him against that day."
John Suppe
Member of the U.S. Academy of Sciences and noted professor of geology at Princeton, expert in the are of tectonics, began a long search for God as a Christian faculty member. He began attending services in the Princeton Chapel, reading the Bible and other Christian books. He committed Himself to Christ and had his first real experience of Christian fellowship in Taiwan, where he is on a fellowship. He states:
Some non–scientist Christians, when they meet a Christian, will call on to debate evolution. That is definitely the wrong thing to do. If you know what problems scientists have in their lives—pride, selfish ambition, jealousy—that's exactly the kind of thing Jesus Christ said that He came to resolve by His death on the cross. Science is full of people with very strong egos who get into conflict with each other. The gospel is the same for scientists as it is for anyone. Evolution is basically a red herring; if scientists are looking for meaning in their lives, it won't be found in evolution. I have never met a non–Christian who brought up evolution with me.
Richard Bube
For many years, Bube was the chairman of the department of materials science at Stanford and carried out foundational work on solid state physics concerning semiconductors. He said:
There are proportionately as many atheistic truck drivers as there are atheistic scientists.
The above comes from a Scientists and Their Gods by Professor Henry F. (Fritz) Schaefer is one of the most distinguished physical scientists in the world
|
|
MisterE
Social climber
|
|
I like the idea that Atheists are not non-believers, they just believe in things most of us take for granted, and/or consider mundane from a spiritual perspective.
That is a theism that shows wonderful appreciation of the present - the here and now.
|
|
P.Rob
Social climber
Pacomia, Ca - Y Que?
|
|
khanom
If I can submit my personal experience I have found God to make Himself rather inconvenient in the non believers life – showing up in the most unlikely places and fashion. He is not afraid of our disbelief and I contend he is always showing Himself to rascals……… all one has to do is read the Bible and it is filled with rascals running into God
P.S. Good evening Doc - I hope you are doing well
|
|
donini
Trad climber
Ouray, Colorado
|
|
I want one!!!
|
|
P.Rob
Social climber
Pacomia, Ca - Y Que?
|
|
I can understand your anger, and what I am about to share is as a personal place in my life as I have ever posted on ST. Regardless of what Dr.F has speculated, I actually have more than a passing education - Pastorial Studies, Philosphy of religion plus Critical Incidents Stress Management (CISM) certification. Conservative Seminary , inner city Pastorial Ministry - .... I say all this to let you know that my 24 year old daughter - my youngest child, is involved in a same sex relationship with a very intelligent, wonderful young woman. I have never seen my daughter so happy, so alive and I do believe they will marry some day. She tells me that I am not allowed to be the officiate, as I will walk her down the isle ......
|
|
MisterE
Social climber
|
|
Frankly, I never can tell what he really believes. It involves calling people stupid? Stupidism?
It sounds rather 5th grade to me - maybe that is his dig.
"I WILL SHOW YOU ALL HOW YOU RESPOND AT AN ADOLESCENT LEVEL! BWAHAHAHAHA!"
As if, somehow that wasn't an adolescent provocation to begin with.
Not dissing the guy for his achievements, just the level at which he chooses to "draw people out".
It could be Elder wisdom, from what I have read - but it isn't.
|
|
BLUEBLOCR
Social climber
joshua tree
|
|
I know Werner,,,
Hung with m, worked with m, climbed with m. I've seen his heart...
I'd say he's a lot like Jesus. He doesn't h8 the sinner for being stupid.
He h8's the sin of being stupid!
Jus Sayin
BB
|
|
Andree Hussar
Social climber
ny
|
|
Atheism is a belief and you are your own God... that is your religion.
|
|
|
SuperTopo on the Web
|