Trip Report
A Dream of White Horses - a trip to the sea cliffs of North Wales (Feb 11-12)
Thursday March 22, 2012 5:21pm
Ever since I decided to matriculate at Cambridge I was on the search for climbs that I had to complete before the end of my year in the UK. Two routes stuck out to me as must do routes: a route on the Old Man of Hoy (E1 5a) and A Dream of White Horses (aka Dream for short). This was back when I had no clue about gritstone and all I could think of were long, inspiring lines like those that one finds in Yosemite Valley, and if I could tick these two climbs I would be satiated with climbing in the UK. When I got to Cambridge I joined the CUMC (Cambridge University Mountaineering Club) and our many trips to the Peak District meant that grit was on the menu most weekends. Needless to say, I have come to love climbing on grit and have had more days climbing outside than I expected considering the normally gloomy weather in this country (we’ve had an abnormally sunny season is what I’ve been told). I have since added a lot of classic grit routes to my tick list and have grown a little bolder, drawing inspiration from British climbers who have been toughened by the no-bolt ethic that is strictly adhered to on grit. All this being said, long lines are the meat and potatoes of why I continue to climb and climbing on grit, above all other things, served as great training for exactly these kind of lines.

For any climber that is new to the trad scene in the UK the first obstacle is the grading system. What follows is an introduction to the trad grading system and it will become clear how it differs from most grading systems that we in the States are familiar with. The grading system in the UK consists of two grades, a technical grade and an adjective grade. The techinical grade is what we would expect it to be; it is supposed to be a reflection of the single hardest move on a pitch. The adjective grade on the other hand is a reflection of the overall seriousness of the climb. At first this system was a little confusing and I was never certain if the climb I was getting on was within my limits or not (in hindsight, this may have been a good thing) but in every system there is a logic to the madness. Once the system was explained to me it became clear to me that a lot of information about a climb could be conveyed through it and I have come to love it. Every adjective grade has a baseline technical grade associated with it. The following is the list of adjective grades, in ascending order, along with the British tech baselines:
Mod (Moderate), Diff (Difficult), VDiff (Very Difficult), HVD (Hard Very Difficult) - these are all easy enough that no tech grade is usually associated with them
S (Severe) - 4a
HS (Hard S) - 4b
VS (Very S) - 4c
HVS (Hard VS) - 5a, YDS equivalent ~5.9
E1 (start of the Extremely hard/severe/difficult routes) - 5b, YDS equivalent ~5.10a/b
E2 - 5c
etc.

If a route is high in the adjective grade but low in tech this would imply a bold/committing/longer than usual climb. Time for Tea (http://tinyurl.com/75bsr8k);, put up by Ed Drummond in 1975 (he put up Dream and the Longhope Route), is a good example of a climb that is bold for a 5c climb. On the other hand, a climb that has a high tech grade but has a low adjective is as the British like to say, “safe as houses but hard as nails”. Eliminator (http://tinyurl.com/7bzvb5n); at Stanage, which I recently ticked, is a good example of this type of climbing -- gear at your waist at every hard move. Applying this system to some climbs in the Valley its utility becomes quickly apparent. For example, the Steck-Salaté route on the Sentinel -- it is considered a ‘hard’ 5.9 (I wouldn’t know from personal experience but from my recollection Clint seems to agree). This route would probably be given an E1 5a grade according to the British system, reflecting the fact that it is a little more serious than your average 5.9 and in fact, taking this further, you could probably add an adjective grade to most of the Tuolumne slab climbs that were established early on. Anyway, I think I’ve bored you all enough with details of how the British system works and I should get back to describing my experience of climbing a classic -- A Dream of White Horses (HVS 4c).

As with all climbing trips from Cambridge, the trip to North Wales includes driving at least four hours with unpredictable weather once at the destination. This weekend's crew consisted of just one car -- Andrew Marshall, Ed Feldman, Celyn Thorpe, Liam Carter and myself -- the others in the club were put off by the possibility of bad weather (and I would have been too except that I could not pass up the possibility of ticking Dream). We had the luxury of Celyn’s parents’ house for basecamp, this meant coming back to home cooked food and a warm bed -- we were spoiled. Their house is located just outside the town of Caernarfon and on a clear day one can see all the way across to the Isle of Anglesey from the window. Much to my dismay, I woke up on Saturday morning and couldn’t see Anglesey. We took a quick look at the forecast and decided that we would have a better shot at climbing at Gogarth on Sunday and so we went to Tremadog (pronounced tre-mad-eck for those of us who don’t speak Welsh) for the day to climb on slightly damp volcanic something (thanks Laurence Cowton for the correction). The climbing at Tremadog was had its surprises but I will leave those stories for another day. Homemade pizza for dinner and dreams of good weather capped the night.

A Dream of White Horses is chronicled in the book, “Hard Rock”, by Royal Robbins’. His write up of the climb can be found in this thread (elegant prose to which mine cannot be compared) - http://tinyurl.com/7bxwc93.

top left corner top right corner
Leo Dickinson's classic photograph of Ed Drummond and Dave Pearce on t...
Leo Dickinson's classic photograph of Ed Drummond and Dave Pearce on the first ascent of A Dream of White Horses.
Credit: Leo Dickinson
bottom left corner bottom right corner

The above photo is one that will forever be etched in my mind and it characterizes the atmosphere of this climb very accurately. This photo together with Robbins’s prose had built up great expectations of this climb for me. That morning's drive to Anglesey was filled with excitement and that weird feeling that only climbers understand, the one that creeps in when taking on a climb that is a little more serious than your everyday climb. We were soon at the rappel anchors and my stomach was churning.

top left corner top right corner
Looking down into the climb at Ed belaying Drew.
Looking down into the climb at Ed belaying Drew.
Credit: nouveau
bottom left corner bottom right corner

We decided that we would all climb Dream, with Ed and Drew leading the charge as a pair while Celyn, Liam and myself climbed in a separate group. Since Dream is a climb that traverses a significant amount (much like On the Lamb in Tuolumne) it was imperative that every climber in the party was climbing at the required level. Now add to this the fact that once you are past the first pitch the only escape from Wen Zawn is by finishing Dream and this becomes a rather committing affair (especially for a group of climbers whose limit is HVS). At HVS 4c the climbing is a romp but as the grade indicates it is a very committing climb. Celyn is a super strong climber (with far superior technique than myself) but she wasn’t keen on leading because of the exposure so Liam and I were left swinging leads. To be honest, Celyn wasn’t super psyched to be following either and it was only the promise that we would scatter cookies along the length of each pitch that convinced her to join us.

top left corner top right corner
Drew on P1.
Drew on P1.
Credit: nouveau
bottom left corner bottom right corner
top left corner top right corner
Ed and Drew on P1.
Ed and Drew on P1.
Credit: nouveau
bottom left corner bottom right corner

Once Drew was at the first belay station I rapped into the climb and we were on, committed to climb Dream. The rappel in felt very eerie but nothing like the feeling I would get looking into the Zawn from above the middle of the last pitch. I set off on the first pitch was as beautiful as Robbins describes it. Holds reveal themselves when you look for them, feet in just the right places and protections nicely spaced out -- I was in a state of flow and soon enough at the end of P1.

top left corner top right corner
Me on the first pitch with a view of the zawn in the background.
Me on the first pitch with a view of the zawn in the background.
Credit: nouveau
bottom left corner bottom right corner
top left corner top right corner
Celyn on route to the P2 belay with Drew (in the background) b...
Celyn on route to the P2 belay with Drew (in the background) battling the last pitch.
Credit: nouveau
bottom left corner bottom right corner

While Liam was firing up the second pitch, Ed and Drew had finished the climb and took on the role of professional photographers and began setting up a rappel anchor above the final pitch.

top left corner top right corner
Liam racking up for P2.
Liam racking up for P2.
Credit: nouveau
bottom left corner bottom right corner
top left corner top right corner
Liam making delicate moves on Wen Slab (White Slab in Welsh), ...
Liam making delicate moves on Wen Slab (White Slab in Welsh), the lighthouse in the background on the far right.
Credit: Ed Feldman
bottom left corner bottom right corner
top left corner top right corner
Ed taking a hands free rest on the exit pitch.
Ed taking a hands free rest on the exit pitch.
Credit: nouveau
bottom left corner bottom right corner
top left corner top right corner
Ed looking absolutely terrified while playing the part of professional...
Ed looking absolutely terrified while playing the part of professional photographer.
Credit: Drew Marshall
bottom left corner bottom right corner
top left corner top right corner
Drew monkeying around above the final pitch.
Drew monkeying around above the final pitch.
Credit: Ed Feldman
bottom left corner bottom right corner

Another stunning pitch flowed by smoothly and Liam was setup at the second hanging belay. As I took him off belay I made the mistake of dropping my belay device, gah. Since there was no real descent and we were climbing in threes this was more of an inconvenience than anything else. By this time I thought my bladder was just about ready to explode and as soon as Celyn left the first belay I turned towards the ocean and breathed a sigh of relief. I wasn’t the only one who was having trouble with bladder control though. Liam had been holding it in ever since I brought him into the first belay and forgot to go after setting up the second belay. Under normal circumstances one would be left wondering how you can forget to take a piss if you’ve been holding it in for this long but I found it in myself to forgive him considering the atmosphere of this pitch, :D. It was only after he brought Celyn and I upto the second belay that he decided that he needed to let loose; this was a hanging belay, mind you, and Celyn wasn’t pleased :D. This wasn’t Liam’s only transgression on the climb -- he had, in the meantime, finished all of Celyn’s ‘send’ cookies, which resulted in a bit of a motivation issue on the third pitch :P.

top left corner top right corner
Leaving the belay and starting up P3.
Leaving the belay and starting up P3.
Credit: Ed Feldman
bottom left corner bottom right corner

With the start of the final pitch staring at us and our professional photographers setup to capture us on this wild pitch, I turned the psyche on. As soon as I got going I got hit with disco legs. I didn’t think I was afraid but it just refused to go away throughout the pitch, maybe it was a reflection of a hidden nervousness inside of me. This pitch was still wet from Saturday with plenty of seepage along the way and I was glad that I had decided to carry a hand towel as part of my rack (a habit that I have developed while climbing in the UK). The line on this pitch was not very obvious and I was never able to guess more than two to three moves ahead. This coupled with the expanse of the zawn below me made the climbing on this pitch unforgettable.

top left corner top right corner
Start of the escape pitch.
Start of the escape pitch.
Credit: nouveau
bottom left corner bottom right corner
top left corner top right corner
The void below. Amazing position with stomach churning exposure, loved...
The void below. Amazing position with stomach churning exposure, loved every second of it.
Credit: Andrew Marshall
bottom left corner bottom right corner

At many points along this pitch I was left staring directly down at the water. I came to the crux and it involved reaching around a block not knowing what you were aiming for with the void of the zawn below me. But as always on this climb a big jug and the appropriate feet could not remain hidden for long. I finished the pitch, setup the belay, and as I was pulling the rope in it turned into a ball of spaghetti at the other belay. This took a good half hour to sort out and by the time Celyn started climbing again I realized that we were in for a tight finish.

top left corner top right corner
Me belaying Celyn on the final pitch with Liam in the background.
Me belaying Celyn on the final pitch with Liam in the background.
Credit: Ed Feldman
bottom left corner bottom right corner

Celyn was going strong until the crux of last pitch, but without the help of the ‘send’ cookies her courage waned and a bit of a panic attack ensued. We lost a little more time while we cajoled her back into climbing mode. All of this was not helping Liam’s case, and by the time he left the belay and worked a stuck nut free daylight had started fading fast. Using the faint light that was cast on the climb by the distant lighthouse and a headlamp shone by Ed from the promontory Liam clawed his way through the climb barely able to make out the handholds. Liam was a real trooper considering that this was his first multi-pitch and he was benighted. At the belay, my feet felt like wooden stumps but I could not have been happier as Liam’s head poked out and we started sorting our gear. Now lay the most dangerous part of the day -- the 4 hour drive back to the flat lands of Cambridgeshire.

  Trip Report Views: 7,209
nouveau
About the Author
nouveau is a climber who used to live in San Francisco, CA (currently in England, and learning to be brave) who would be posting these trip reports on the Rants & Raves section of Craigslist if it weren't the case that SuperTopo users humour punters.

Comments
PhilG

Trad climber
The Circuit, Tonasket WA
  Mar 22, 2012 - 05:41pm PT
Stellar trip reports.
Makes me want to book a flight to the UK today Also brings back fond memories of the wee bit of sea cliff climbing I did when I was there.
Thanks.
micronut

Trad climber
Fresno/Clovis, ca
  Mar 22, 2012 - 06:29pm PT
Proud send. Way to fight the demons and crank it out on the sharp end. An adventure you'll remember for a long time I'm sure.
cowpoke

climber
  Mar 22, 2012 - 06:37pm PT
Outstanding ...the pics are amazing
Dolomite

climber
Anchorage
  Mar 22, 2012 - 06:37pm PT
Terrific report! Thanks so much for sharing it with us.
ontheedgeandscaredtodeath

Social climber
Wilds of New Mexico
  Mar 22, 2012 - 06:46pm PT
Super cool- thanks!
Russ Walling

Social climber
from Poofters Froth, Wyoming
  Mar 22, 2012 - 06:52pm PT
Very nice!
survival

Big Wall climber
Terrapin Station
  Mar 22, 2012 - 06:53pm PT
Wow, that next to last pic is totally worth the price of admission!
Andy Fielding

Trad climber
UK
  Mar 22, 2012 - 08:17pm PT
Thanks for the report. This is a fantastic route and one I have been fortunate to do first in 1980 and then again in 1982. It's a "must do" for anyone that finds themselves in the area. Below is a montage (it's a poor quality scan of some photos I stuck together, digital cameras were si fi when I climbed this) showing the whole of the route with me and my partner appearing several times. The route is essentially a rising traverse from bottom right to top left.

thekidcormier

Gym climber
squamish, b.c.
  Mar 22, 2012 - 08:34pm PT
Right on! sick line, what the grade?
Reilly

Mountain climber
The Other Monrovia- CA
  Mar 23, 2012 - 01:21am PT
what the grade?


Which 'e told you, didn't 'e? HVS 4c
That's 5.8 to you, mate. I know the OP says 5.9 but I got up it so
it can't be 5.9. Besides, I think 'e was 'aving us on with a bit
o' the ol' camera tiltin' and all. ;-)



Definitely one of the best climbs anywhere.
It looks a wee bit cleaner than when I did it. You can date it well
enough from the sartorial splendor and state-of-the-art gear.



wayne burleson

climber
Amherst, MA
  Mar 22, 2012 - 08:58pm PT
Great trip report! And in the grand tradition of Robbins and Drummond you told us the real story with emotions and honesty...
yo

climber
Mudcat Spire
  Mar 22, 2012 - 11:05pm PT
Wanna do that route so bad.
Ezra Ellis

Trad climber
North wet, and Da souf
  Mar 22, 2012 - 11:20pm PT
Nice, I've always wanted to climb on the seat cliffs,
Thanks!!
neebee

Social climber
calif/texas
  Mar 22, 2012 - 11:39pm PT
hey there say, nouveau... thanks for this very nice share...

will have to come back later to see the rest...
thanks so much!
:)
Abenda

climber
  Mar 23, 2012 - 12:20am PT
Thats a super TR. One of the best on ST.
nouveau

Trad climber
San Francisco, CA
Author's Reply  Mar 23, 2012 - 03:57am PT
The route is graded HVS 4c which, as Reilly said, is equivalent to YDS 5.8. I wasn't clear in the post even though I went on for so long. The British tech grade is what one should look at when making pure conversions between YDS and British grade (for the most part anyway). I think HVS 5a is more like 5.9. The route gets the HVS grade purely because of the commitment factor.
Clint Cummins

Trad climber
SF Bay area, CA
  Mar 24, 2012 - 12:07am PT
Great report and spectactular photos, Job!
Thanks for sharing.

Will you bring cookies again, and will they get to the intended person? :-)
Patrick Sawyer

climber
Originally California, now Ireland
  Mar 23, 2012 - 08:17am PT
I have always wanted to do Dream. Maybe if I can get back in shape (in more ways than one), hop on the Stena ferry out of Dun Laoghaire (about two hours across the Irish Sea to Holyhead), I could be at Dream in under three hours.

Great TR Nouveau
Dos XX

Trad climber
Los Angeles, CA
  Mar 23, 2012 - 10:13am PT
What a great adventure!
cowpoke

climber
  Mar 23, 2012 - 03:49pm PT
I just love the photos of this climb...beautiful, dramatic setting
looking sketchy there...

Social climber
Lassitude 33
  Mar 23, 2012 - 05:20pm PT
Did this in 82. Brings back memories, including a great trundle we did right into the Zawn.
LongAgo

Trad climber
  Mar 24, 2012 - 01:27am PT
Route is quite wonderful with pounding ocean, unique rock and of course rubbing shoulders with English climbers along the way. However, the wall is not as steep as in some pictures here, and no move or section is over 5.8. The English rating system does include a nudge for exposure and overall position and commitment there above the sea with no easy rap off possible, but if you can climb 5.8, you can do this spectacular route, well, unless your mind gets in the way.

Other English cliffs sometimes have very serious mental factors with significant run outs and fall dangers. Consult with reliable locals who will level with you on protection and dangers. O, and watch the weather closely.
Mighty Hiker

climber
Outside the Asylum
  Mar 24, 2012 - 01:58am PT
Thanks for a nice report!

White horses have a special place in mythology, and English tradition. It's also a metaphor for a wave - in Greek mythology, Poseidon created horses out of breaking waves. It's a rather poetic and apt name for a route.
justthemaid

climber
Jim Henson's Basement
  Mar 24, 2012 - 09:19am PT
Great report. That place looks amazing.
Dirka

Trad climber
Hustle City
  Mar 24, 2012 - 10:06am PT
Sweet.
Zander

climber
  Mar 29, 2012 - 12:01am PT
So nice.
Thanks,
Zander
Rolfr

Sport climber
Penticton BC
  Mar 29, 2012 - 12:41am PT
Man, I so love your post, that route is definitely on my bucket list!
Go